Evidence #244 | September 27, 2021

Book of Mormon Evidence: Colophons (Complexity)

Post contributed by

 

Scripture Central

Abstract

Book of Mormon colophons manifest several patterns, demonstrating one aspect of the Book of Mormon’s editorial complexity and internal continuity.

Colophons in the Book of Mormon

Nephite authors frequently supplied editorial comments, often referred to as colophons, at the beginning and end of the Book of Mormon’s literary units. Some colophons can be identified by their use of a sentence fragment, rather than a complete sentence, to formally introduce a textual unit. For instance, the first words of the ancient heading for the book of 1 Nephi read: “An account of Lehi and his wife Sariah, and his four sons, being called, (beginning at the eldest) Laman, Lemuel, Sam, and Nephi.” Such headings will be defined as “formal colophons” in this summary.

Less formal colophons, utilizing complete sentences, are also found near the beginning (and also the end) of many Book of Mormon texts. Together, these formal and informal editorial insertions “serve as markers and natural divisions in the text.”1

Nephi inscribing a metal record. Image via churchofjesuschrist.org. 

Nephi’s introduction—which contains a lengthy formal colophon, followed by an informal colophon—provides an apt example. In the earliest manuscripts, Nephi’s first book begins with the title “The Book of Nephi” and is followed by “His Reign and Ministry” (perhaps intended as a subtitle).2 An overview of content is then given in a formal heading (not to be confused with the italicized heading, which is of modern origin).3 This ancient heading introduces Nephi’s family, summarizes the narrative events in his account, and then concludes with a statement of authorship: “This is according to the account of Nephi; or in other words, I, Nephi, wrote this record.”

Nephi’s formal introductory colophon is then followed by an informal colophon containing further introductory data. In it, Nephi supplies information about the following topics: (1) authorship, (2) parentage, (3) credentials, (4) recordkeeping, (5) language, (6) and authentication:

I, Nephi [authorship], having been born of goodly parents [parentage], therefore I was taught somewhat in all the learning of my father; and having seen many afflictions in the course of my days, nevertheless, having been highly favored of the Lord in all my days; yea, having had a great knowledge of the goodness and the mysteries of God [credentials], therefore I make a record [recordkeeping] of my proceedings in my days. Yea, I make a record in the language of my father, which consists of the learning of the Jews and the language of the Egyptians [language]. And I know that the record which I make is true; and I make it with mine own hand; and I make it according to my knowledge [authentication]. (1 Nephi 1:1–3)

An example of a formal colophon in the middle of a book (yet still at the beginning of a textual unit) can be seen in Mosiah 9. This chapter begins with a brief insertion letting readers know that the account about to be given draws directly from the record of Zeniff:

The Record of Zeniff [source text/authorship]—An account of his people, from the time they left the land of Zarahemla until the time that they were delivered out of the hands of the Lamanites [content preview].

The last two verses of the book of Helaman provide an example of a colophon that shows up at the end of a book:

And thus ended [conclusion] the ninetieth year [chronology] of the reign of the judges over the people of Nephi. And thus ended [conclusion] the book of Helaman [title], according to the record of Helaman and his sons [source text]. (Helaman 16:24–25)

The Book of Mormon’s editorial comments have parallels with colophons found in a variety of in ancient Near Eastern texts.4 Yet the colophons developed by Nephite authors also manifest several original features, as would be expected for an independent literary tradition that developed in the Americas for nearly a thousand years.

Conceptual Patterns in Book of Mormon Colophons

Colophons in the Book of Mormon do not have a rigid form or structure, but they still manifest a number of patterns and consistencies. For instance, most of the text’s colophons contain clusters (typically 3 or more) of the following concepts:

  • audience (who the text or author is addressing)
  • authentication (some type of verification or validation of words in a text)
  • authorship (the author or authors of a text)
  • blessing (a blessing promised or sometimes pronounced upon the reader or upon God)
  • conclusion (any type of formal concluding statement)
  • chronology (an indication of time in the form of a specific date, the passage of years, or sometimes more general designations)
  • content preview (details about what will be discussed in a text, usually in summary form)
  • content review (details that were previously discussed in a text, usually in summary form)
  • credentials (an author’s position, status, or other features that increase credibility)
  • exhortation (strong admonition to the audience to either do or avoid doing something)
  • family (family members of the author, typically a brother)
  • language (language in which a text was given or in which the author has been instructed)
  • lineage (the author’s ancestors)
  • location (the location of the events in the text or where a speech or other discourse was given)
  • parentage (statements about an author’s parents, usually about a father)
  • posterity (statements about an author’s children or descendants)
  • purpose (the author’s purpose in writing or including a text)
  • recordkeeping (any statement about the recording of history)
  • source plates (statements about the plates upon which a text is written)
  • source text (statements about the record or account from which a text has been extracted or abridged)
  • title (the formal title of a text)
  • warning (usually a warning of physical or spiritual danger given to the audience)

The repeated concentration of these concepts suggests that the Nephite authors held fairly consistent ideas about what topics should be addressed at the beginning and ending of literary units.

Book Headings

An example of a more formulaic pattern can be seen in the heading information of several books. Except for the books of Enos through Mosiah (which don’t have formal headings), each book, as well as the Title Page in the Book of Mormon, begins with a title named after an individual, sometimes followed by a subtitle describing more about that individual. The titles in 8 of these 11 books are then followed by a sentence fragment (rather than a complete sentence) which describes the contents of the record and typically its authorship.5 Furthermore, 6 of these 8 sentence fragments begin with the words “An account” or “The account.”6 These consistencies can be seen in the chart below:7

Book

Colophon

Title Page

Title: The Book of Mormon

Intro: An account written by the hand of Mormon …

1 Nephi

Title: The [First] Book of Nephi

Subtitle: His Reign and Ministry

Intro: An account of Lehi and his wife Sariah, …

2 Nephi

Title: The [Second] Book of Nephi

Intro: An account of the death of Lehi. …

Jacob

Title: The Book of Jacob

Intro: The words of his preaching unto his brethren. …

Alma

Title: The Book of Alma

Subtitle: The Son of Alma

Intro: The account of Alma, who was the son of Alma, …

Helaman

Title: The Book of Helaman

Intro: An account of the Nephites. …

3 Nephi

Title: [Third Nephi] The Book of Nephi

Subtitle: The Son of Nephi, Who Was the Son of Helaman …

4 Nephi

Title: [Fourth Nephi] The Book of Nephi

Subtitle: Who is the son of Nephi …

Intro: An account of the people of Nephi, …

Mormon

Title: The Book of Mormon

Ether

Title: The Book of Ether

Intro: The record of the Jaredites, …

Moroni

Title: The Book of Moroni

“According to …”

Another typical feature can be seen in the phrase “according to” followed by the designation of a source text. The conclusion of the heading for the book of 1 Nephi states: “This is according to the account of Nephi.” Likewise, the conclusion to the heading of the book of Alma reads: “And also an account of a war between the Nephites and the Lamanites, according to the record of Alma, the first and chief judge.” Mormon was particularly prone to use this phrasing in his abridgment, where it shows up in 13 of the 28 colophons identified in the books of Alma through 4 Nephi.8

In a related but different example, the authors in the books of Jarom and Omni mentioned that they were keeping their record “according to the commandment(s)” of their fathers. This pattern, demonstrated in the following chart, is unique to these writers of the small plates, who, unlike Mormon, weren’t abridging other records and gave only brief introductory and concluding remarks.

Scripture

Text

Jarom 1:1

“Now behold, I, Jarom, write a few words according to the commandment of my father, Enos …”

Jarom 1:15

“And I deliver these plates into the hands of my son Omni, that they may be kept according to the commandments of my fathers

Omni 1:3

“Yea, and in fine, two hundred and eighty and two years had passed away, and I had kept these plates according to the commandments of my fathers

Omni 1:19

“And after this manner we keep the records, for it is according to the commandments of our fathers.”

In total, the Book of Mormon contains over 90 identified colophons at the beginning or near the end of textual units. Exhaustive analysis remains to be completed, and further research may reveal additional consistencies and patterns. For a comprehensive list of Book of Mormon colophons with typical conceptual features identified, see the Appendix.

Conclusion

While adhering to some editorial features found in ancient Near Eastern texts, the authors of Book of Mormon colophons appear to have developed their own traditions and to have formulated their own patterns of use, sometimes with tendencies unique to individual authors/editors or to groups of writers from the same time period. Although not overly rigid or formulaic, these patterns demonstrate an important aspect of the Book of Mormon’s subtle complexity and internal continuity. “That complexity,” notes Thomas W. Mackay, “is emphasized by various contextual source indicators or colophons for documents and authors, remnants of the materials Mormon used to compile his edited summary of Nephite history.”9

Further Reading
Appendix
Endnotes
Complexity
Editing
Colophons (Complexity)
Book of Mormon

© 2024 Scripture Central: A Non-Profit Organization. All rights reserved. Registered 501(c)(3). EIN: 20-5294264