Evidence #392 | February 14, 2023

Book of Mormon Evidence: Brass Plates Consistencies

Post contributed by

 

Scripture Central

Abstract

The Book of Mormon’s presentation of the brass plates involves a degree of editorial complexity and realism that is hard to ascribe to Joseph Smith’s natural ability.

One way to investigate the Book of Mormon’s authenticity is to look at the way it handles its underlying source texts, as well as the major sets of plates from which they derive. This evidence summary will specifically assess statements made about the brass plates.

Descriptions of the Contents of the Brass Plates

Nephite authors made numerous specific claims about the origin, contents, and history of the brass plates.1 In addition, they sometimes invoked certain words, phrases, or ideas when discussing this topic. Although it is likely missing some relevant data, the list below shows that the number of these claims and associated details is not insignificant.2

1. The record was “engraven upon plates of brass” (1 Nephi 3:3).

2. The brass plates were possessed by a man named “Laban” (1 Nephi 3:3).

3. The brass plates contained a “genealogy” of Lehi’s forefathers (1 Nephi 3:3).

4. The brass plates contained “a record of the Jews” (1 Nephi 5:12).

5. The history described in the brass plates spanned “from the beginning, even down to the commencement of the reign of Zedekiah” (1 Nephi 5:12).

6. The brass plates contained the “five books of Moses” (1 Nephi 5:11) which included the “law of Moses” (1 Nephi 4:15–16).

7. The brass plates contained an account of the “creation of the world” (1 Nephi 5:11).

8. The brass plates contained an account of “Adam and Eve, who were our first parents” (1 Nephi 5:11).

9. The brass plates contained the “prophecies of the holy prophets” (1 Nephi 5:13).

10. The brass plates contained “prophecies … concerning Joseph, who was carried into Egypt” (2 Nephi 4:1), as well as information about Joseph as Lehi’s ancestor.

11. The brass plates contained “many prophecies … of Jeremiah” (1 Nephi 5:13).

12. The brass plates contained the writings of “Isaiah” (1 Nephi 15:20).

13. The brass plates contained the writings of “Zenock” (1 Nephi 19:10).

14. The brass plates contained the writings of “Neum” (1 Nephi 19:10).

15. The brass plates contained the writings of “Zenos” (1 Nephi 19:10).

16. The brass plates contained the writings of “Ezias” (Helaman 8:20).

17. Nephi claimed the brass plates would “preserve unto our children the language of our fathers” (1 Nephi 3:19).

18. The brass plates were necessary so that Nephi’s posterity wouldn’t “dwindle and perish in unbelief” (1 Nephi 4:13).

19. The brass plates were described as being of “great worth” (1 Nephi 5:21).

20. The brass plates were described as being for “profit and learning” (1 Nephi 19:23).

21. The brass plates were associated with the Lord’s covenantal promise involving blessings and curses related to land and prosperity (1 Nephi 4:14).

22. The brass plates were associated with “mysteries” (Mosiah 1:3–5).

23. The brass plates were associated with the idea of “remembrance” (Mosiah 1:3).

24. The brass plates were associated with the concept of “testimony” and with multiple or additional “witnesses” (1 Nephi 22:30).

25. The brass plates were associated with forms of the words “keep” and “preserve” (Mosiah 1:4–5).

26. It was emphasized that the contents of the brass plates “are true” (Mosiah 1:6).

27. The need to “search” the brass plates was emphasized (1 Nephi 5:10).

28. When Nephi fled from his brothers, he “brought the records which were engraven upon the plates of brass” (2 Nephi 5:12).

29. The “ball, or compass” (or “Liahona”) became a sacred relic associated with the brass plates (2 Nephi 5:12).

30. The “sword of Laban” became a sacred relic associated with the brass plates (2 Nephi 5:14).

31. The Nephite “interpreters” became a sacred relic associated with the brass plates (Mosiah 28:20).

32. Lehi prophesied that the brass plates wouldn’t be “dimmed any more by time” (1 Nephi 5:19).

33. Lehi prophesied that the brass plates would “go forth unto all nations, kindreds, tongues, and people” (1 Nephi 5:18).

Clustering of Elements

Almost all of these 33 elements can be found in multiple places in the Book of Mormon,3 as demonstrated in the following chart.4 For the specific statements in each of these chapters, as well as the verses involved, see the Appendix.

Rather than just one or two points of correspondence, we occasionally encounter substantial convergences of elements, sometimes five or more in a single chapter or short span of verses (see rows highlighted in gray). Significantly, there is no single chapter or textual unit from which all of the relevant data pertaining to the brass plates could be derived. Instead, we find a hodgepodge of textual relationships, where later texts often relate to scattered statements about the brass plates from various earlier sources.5 These blended consistencies hint at the existence of a genuine body of underlying source texts, as well as the development of a nuanced scribal tradition in relation to those source texts.6

Subtle Textual Relationships

While some textual connections are notable due to a complex network of shared elements, others are impressive because they involve an exclusive, obscure, or subtle relationship. For instance, after a lengthy discussion of the contents of the brass plates, Nephi stated, “I did liken all scriptures unto us, that it might be for our profit and learning” (1 Nephi 19:23). Several chapters later in 2 Nephi 4:15, Nephi echoed this sentiment:

1 Nephi 19:23

2 Nephi 4:15

And I did read many things unto them which were written in the books of Moses [from the brass plates]; but that I might more fully persuade them to believe in the Lord their Redeemer I did read unto them that which was written by the prophet Isaiah [from the plates of brass]; for I did liken all scriptures unto us, that it might be for our profit and learning.

And upon these I write the things of my soul, and many of the scriptures which are engraven upon the plates of brass. For my soul delighteth in the scriptures, and my heart pondereth them, and writeth them for the learning and the profit of my children.

Both of these passages were written by the same author, both characterize the writings from the brass plates as “scripture,” and both invoke a two-part element (“profit” and “learning”).7 It is therefore hard to see them as anything other than a consistent detail related directly to the author’s conception of the brass plates and their scriptural content.

Another unique textual connection can be seen in Alma’s counsel to his son Helaman in Alma 37, which correlates to Lehi’s prophecy given all the way back in 1 Nephi 5. Significantly, these are the only two passages in the entire Book of Mormon that mention this multi-element prophecy:

1 Nephi 5

Alma 37

14 And it came to pass that my father, Lehi, also found upon the plates of brass a genealogy of his fathers

17 And now when my father saw all these things, he was filled with the Spirit, and began to prophesy concerning his seed—

18 That these plates of brass should go forth unto all nations, kindreds, tongues, and people who were of his seed.

19 Wherefore, he said that these plates of brass should never perish; neither should they be dimmed any more by time. And he prophesied many things concerning his seed.

3 And these plates of brass, which contain these engravings, which have the records of the holy scriptures upon them, which have the genealogy of our forefathers, even from the beginning—

4 Behold, it has been prophesied by our fathers, that they should be kept and handed down from one generation to another, and be kept and preserved by the hand of the Lord until they should go forth unto every nation, kindred, tongue, and people, that they shall know of the mysteries contained thereon.

5 And now behold, if they are kept they must retain their brightness; yea, and they will retain their brightness; yea, and also shall all the plates which do contain that which is holy writ.

A third—although certainly not the last—example of a less-than-obvious textual relationship can be seen in the accounts of the conversions of Lamoni and his father, found in Alma 18 and Alma 22. What is interesting about these passages is that they don’t directly mention the brass plates at all. Instead, they only mention the “scriptures.” Yet when one compares the surrounding content in each account with the details in 1 Nephi 5 (where the brass plates are first described), it becomes clear that the “scriptures” being referenced are undoubtedly from the brass plates themselves:

1 Nephi 5

Alma 18

Alma 22

10 And after they had given thanks unto the God of Israel, my father, Lehi, took the records which were engraven upon the plates of brass, and he did search them from the beginning.

11 And he beheld that they did contain the five books of Moses, which gave an account of the creation of the world, and also of Adam and Eve, who were our first parents;

12 And also a record of the Jews from the beginning, even down to the commencement of the reign of Zedekiah, king of Judah;

13 And also the prophecies of the holy prophets, from the beginning, even down to the commencement of the reign of Zedekiah

36 Now when Ammon had said these words, he began at the creation of the world, and also the creation of Adam, and told him all the things concerning the fall of man, and rehearsed and laid before him the records and the holy scriptures of the people, which had been spoken by the prophets, even down to the time that their father, Lehi, left Jerusalem.

12 And it came to pass that when Aaron saw that the king would believe his words, he began from the creation of Adam, reading the scriptures unto the king—how God created man after his own image, and that God gave him commandments, and that because of transgression, man had fallen.

13 And Aaron did expound unto him the scriptures from the creation of Adam

Biblical Content on the Brass Plates

Since Hebrew authors are known to frequently quote, paraphrase, or allude to past scripture in their writings,8 and since the Book of Mormon itself claims that there is substantial overlap between the Old Testament and the brass plates,9 readers might reasonably expect there to be numerous references to known Old Testament texts throughout the Nephite record. And this is precisely what one finds. While a fully rigorous and comprehensive analysis of all potential textual relationships hasn’t yet been conducted, many studies have already demonstrated that the degree of intertextuality between the Book of Mormon and relevant Old Testament writings is extensive.10

Isaiah by Ted Henninger and Nephi by James Fullmer.

Nowhere is this more evident than in the book of Isaiah, at least 25 chapters of which are either quoted or paraphrased throughout the Book of Mormon.11 While it may be tempting to assume that Joseph Smith used a copy of the Bible to aid his dictation of these chapters, this proposal is contradicted by statements given by the witnesses to the translation.12 It is also rendered somewhat doubtful by the nature of the translation itself,13 as well as evidence suggesting that Joseph may not have even owned a Bible at the time.14

It would, of course, be a remarkable feat of memory for Joseph Smith to have dictated all of these passages from memory. Yet the use of Isaiah in the Book of Mormon goes well beyond rote recitations of biblical content. In many instances, Isaiah’s words are woven into the teachings and prophecies of Nephite authors in a way that would have required no small amount of literary skill, not to mention a deep understanding of the themes and contents of Isaiah’s writings.15 The same is true of the many quotations, paraphrases, and allusions made to other Old Testament texts.

Extrabiblical Content on the Brass Plates

The Book of Mormon also claims, early on, that the brass plates contained sacred writings that aren’t in the Bible (1 Nephi 13:23). In some cases, we only get brief hints of these texts. Only a few statements are attributed to Zenock,16 a single prophecy is attributed to Neum (1 Nephi 19:10), and we don’t know anything specific about the writings of Ezias, other than that they were contained on the brass plates (Helaman 8:20).17 At times, readers even encounter unattributed prophecies or quotations, some of which may have come from the brass plates.18

Roots of Olive Trees by Jody Livingston.

In other chapters, a significant amount of extrabiblical content is either directly quoted or alluded to, including Zenos’s allegory of the olive tree (Jacob 5), Zenos’s prophecies about the calamities surrounding Christ’s death (1 Nephi 19:10–12), several prophecies given by Joseph who was sold into Egypt (2 Nephi 3:4–22; Alma 46:23–27), and numerous statements found in the Book of Moses.19 Such material couldn’t have been recalled from memory or copied from some other source by any would-be forger. The Book of Mormon’s true author—if its own authorial claims are discounted—would have needed to create these underlying documents, some of which are quite intricate.20

Reverse Translation Order

It should be remembered that because of the loss of the 116 pages, the Book of Mormon was dictated out of order, most likely beginning with Mosiah and ending with Words of Mormon.21 This back-to-front dictation process would almost certainly have made the translation more difficult, at least under the assumption that Joseph Smith merely concocted the Book of Mormon from his own imagination.

Chart via Scripture Central. 

This is partially because the references and allusions to the brass plates in Mormon’s abridgment of Nephi’s large plates are liberally scattered throughout the text. We get a few significant concentrations of elements in Mosiah 1, Alma 37, Helaman 8, and 3 Nephi 10, but most of the references and allusions are strewn here and there in smaller clusters of four elements or less (see chart at beginning). It probably would have been much easier to start with the origin story of the plates in 1 Nephi 3–5 in which most (although not all) of the relevant textual data is concentrated in a few chapters, and then build upon that foundation, rather than synthesizing data from an array of prior sources.22

Either way, the task would have been formidable. According to witnesses, Joseph Smith didn’t use any notes or reference materials when dictating the Book of Mormon.23 Thus, when he reached the small plates, he would have needed to mentally recall numerous details about the brass plates scattered throughout Mormon’s abridgment. It is true that some of these details—such as the record being “engraven” upon brass—are not especially significant and could be remembered without much effort. But many other elements would have been much more taxing to reproduce, especially in the aggregate.

An impressive instance of this type of reversed textual relationship can be seen in the account of Christ’s death found in 3 Nephi. After reporting on the great destruction and calamities among the Nephites, Mormon stated, “Yea, the prophet Zenos did testify of these things, and also Zenock spake concerning these things …. And these things which testify of us, are they not written upon the plates of brass” (3 Nephi 10:15–17). Many chapters later, when Joseph Smith dictated the small plates of Nephi, we find a series of prophecies (involving more than a dozen specific elements) that match up closely with the reported fulfillments from 3 Nephi, some of which are indeed attributed to the prophets Zenos and Zenock:

1 Nephi 19

3 Nephi

according to the words of Zenock, and to be crucified, according to the words of Neum, and to be buried in a sepulchre, according to the words of Zenos (v. 10)

And all these things must surely come, saith the prophet Zenos (v. 12)

Yea, the prophet Zenos did testify of these things, and also Zenock spake concerning these things (10:16)

and to be buried in a sepulchre, according to the words of Zenos, which he spake concerning the three days of darkness, which should be a sign given of his death unto those who should inhabit the isles of the sea, more especially given unto those who are of the house of Israel (v. 10)

so great were the mists of darkness which were upon the face of the land. And it came to pass that it did last for the space of three days (8:22–23)

But if not, O house of Israel, the places of your dwellings shall become desolate until the time of the fulfilling of the covenant to your fathers. … And it came to pass that thus did the three days pass away (10:7–10)

For thus spake the prophet: The Lord God surely shall visit all the house of Israel at that day, some with his voice, because of their righteousness (v. 11)

And it came to pass that while they were thus conversing one with another, they heard a voice as if it came out of heaven (11:3)

The Lord God surely shall visit all the house of Israel at that day, some with his voice, because of their righteousness (v. 11)

O all ye that are spared because ye were more righteous (9:13)

The Lord God surely shall visit all the house of Israel at that day, some with his voice, because of their righteousness, unto their great joy and salvation (v. 11)

and no one can conceive of the joy which filled our souls at the time we heard him pray for us unto the Father. … but so great was the joy of the multitude that they were overcome (17:17–18)

and others with the thunderings (v. 11)

there was terrible thunder (8:6)

and the lightnings of his power (v. 11)

there were exceedingly sharp lightnings (8:7)

by tempest (v. 11)

because of the tempest (8:12)

by fire (v. 11)

And the city of Zarahemla did take fire (8:8)

many were burned (8:14)

by smoke, and vapor of darkness (v. 11)

neither were they overpowered by the vapor of smoke and of darkness (10:13)

by the opening of the earth (v. 11)

by the opening of the earth to receive them (10:14)

by mountains which shall be carried up (v. 11)

And the earth was carried up upon the city of Moronihah, that in the place of the city there became a great mountain

And the rocks of the earth must rend; and because of the groanings of the earth … (v. 12)

the earth did cease to tremble, and the rocks did cease to rend, and the dreadful groanings did cease (10:9)

Interestingly, even some writings in the small plates demonstrate an awareness of brass plates content that hadn’t yet been dictated. This can be seen in Nephi’s and Lehi’s allusions to Zenos’s allegory of the Olive tree, as well as in Jacob’s comments in Jacob 4.24 These situations—where authors in the text appear to be intimately familiar with prophecies or revelations from the brass plates that hadn’t yet been dictated—adds a significant measure of realism to the Book of Mormon’s editorial claims.25

Conclusion

When viewed collectively, the Book of Mormon’s reverse-order presentation of the brass plates is highly sophisticated, as dozens of consistent details pertaining to their contents and history are mentioned in various combinations throughout the Nephite record. In addition to the content that would have needed to be created from scratch (like Zenos’s allegory of the Olive tree), hundreds of passages from biblical and extrabiblical texts are either quoted (often verbatim or nearly verbatim) or skillfully integrated (as paraphrases or allusions) into the original writings of Nephite authors.

It is hard to overstate the degree of biblical knowledge, literary talent, editorial conscientiousness, and mental recall that would be required for a single author to fabricate all these details. Even under favorable circumstances—with access to notes, outlines, and plenty of time to draft and revise content—a skilled writer would be hard-pressed to create and infuse this content into an already immensely complex document.26

Joseph Smith translating the Book of Mormon. Image via ChurchofJesusChrist.org.

Yet Joseph Smith didn’t have any of these benefits when he dictated the Book of Mormon in the presence of various scribes in 1829.27 The best available historical evidence indicates that he had little formal education, virtually no known literary experience, and only a limited knowledge of the Bible.28 Furthermore, the dictation process was highly constraining, as Joseph reportedly didn’t rely on any notes or reference materials to help him recall or organize material,29 nor did he make any substantive revisions.30

Nevertheless, in the course of about 60 working days,31 he seamlessly integrated this large array of brass plates material into what was essentially a single—and final—dictated draft. All things considered, the Book of Mormon’s presentation of the brass plates involves a degree of editorial complexity and realism that is hard to ascribe to Joseph Smith’s natural ability. This, in turn, supports his consistent claim that he translated its contents by the gift and power of God.   

Further Reading
Appendix
Endnotes
Complexity
Editing
Brass Plates Consistencies
Book of Mormon

© 2024 Scripture Central: A Non-Profit Organization. All rights reserved. Registered 501(c)(3). EIN: 20-5294264